If you’re searching for a statement gown for your next event, the Manning Cartell Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress is it. In this review, I’m covering everything you need to know—from fit and fabric to styling and where to buy it before it sells out again. Let’s get into it!
This article contains affiliate links, including Amazon Affiliate, Revolve, and Reward Style links. If you purchase using my links, I may earn a small commission. For additional information, please read my privacy policy and full disclosure statement. Thank you for your support!
Table of Contents
The Viral Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress
Spring is quickly approaching, which means formal season is almost here—weddings, proms, and all the best excuses to dress up. And if there’s one dress that has completely taken over, it’s the Manning Cartell Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress. Its disc embellishments create a mermaid-like look, while its structured shape adds a touch of timelessness.
This gown is perfect for everything from black-tie weddings to senior proms—it’s gone viral for a reason. After seeing it all over social media, I finally decided to add it to my collection. I ordered mine directly from the Manning Cartell site, and shipping from Australia to NYC was surprisingly fast.
Now, let’s get into the details—fit, fabric, styling, and whether this dress is worth the hype.
Shop The Look
Manning Cartell Supreme Extreme Dress Pink
Fit and Sizing: Does It Run True to Size?
One of my biggest concerns when ordering from Australian brands is fit—some run small and short compared to US sizing. I typically wear a US 4 and opted for the AU8 / US4 based on reviews. The dress fits true to size, with little to no stretch. I recommend taking your normal size for a sculpted yet perfect fit. The crepe satin bodice is thin, so I opted to go braless with cuplets—most strapless bras were visible underneath. The teardrop lace applique skirt is roomy, so sizing can be more flexible on the body.
Fit Details
- True to size, but no stretch
- Sculpted fit with a secure zip-up closure
- Lightweight despite its structured look
- Bust support: I have a 34B bust and needed cuplets to keep the top in place
- Fabric feel: thin and breathable
If you’re between sizes or prefer a little more room, consider sizing up since the fabric doesn’t stretch.
Tall-Girl Approved?
Yes. At 5’10”, I wore 3-inch heels, and the hemline was perfect. If you’re shorter, taller heels or a minor hem alteration may help keep the proportions balanced.
Fabric and Design: What Makes This Dress Stand Out?
The disc embellishments are what set this dress apart. They create a liquid-like effect when you move, giving off serious modern mermaid energy. The crepe satin bodice is structured yet breathable, which is rare for such an intricate gown.
Despite the detailing, the fabric is easy to maintain. I was surprised to find that the discs are lightweight fabric, so they can be gently steamed to keep them looking flawless.
Available Colors: Which One Should You Get?
This dress comes in three standout shades, each perfect for different occasions:
- Rosewater Pink – A romantic shade that took over social media, perfect for weddings and spring events.
- Aqua Spritz – A bold, fresh blue hue that feels modern and unexpected. This is one of my favorite new arrivals from Manning Cartell!
- Ivory – A sleek, elegant neutral, ideal for modern brides, engagement parties, or evening events.
The dress’ flattering fit and intricate accents pop in every color.
Shop The Look
Blue Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress
Is It Comfortable? What to Expect
Despite its intricate design, the Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress feels surprisingly lightweight, making it easy to wear for hours. The only challenge? The strapless top—those with a smaller bust may need extra support, like cuplets or fashion tape. Otherwise, the structured bodice stays secure on its own.
How I Styled the Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress
Since this dress is already a statement piece, I kept my accessories minimal, adding pops of silver or gold depending on the color.
- For the Rosewater Pink dress, I went with silver details, wearing simple silver earrings and silver slingback pumps to complement the soft pastel shade.
- For the Aqua Spritz dress, I chose gold accents, pairing it with gold flower earrings and gold strappy heels for a warm, elegant touch.
It’s the kind of evening dress that does all the work for you, making styling effortless.
Where to Buy the Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress
This dress sells out fast, but it frequently restocks, so I recommend signing up for notifications and joining the brand’s mailing list. If you miss it, you can also rent it on Pickle—a great option if you have multiple events this season. This app is incredible for last-minute bookings and worth checking out for your next occasion. The hire price is around $175, and they even offer affordable local deliveries if you’re in a major city!
Other Manning Cartell Dresses to Consider
If you love the Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress, here are two other equally stunning styles:
- Supreme Extreme Slip Dress – If you’re not into the pastel colors or strapless style, this is a more classic take on the Balconette Dress.
- Enchantment Balconette Dress – A new style, this romantic red lace dress features 3D floral petals.
- Supreme Extreme Strapless Gown – A black A-line maxi dress with a sheer lace midsection.
Final Thoughts: Is It Worth It?
For $412, this dress delivers a look and feel I’d expect from a far more expensive designer piece. If you want to turn heads this season, the Manning Cartell Supreme Extreme Balconette Dress should be on your list.
Would I buy it again? Let’s just say I already own two… and I’m seriously eyeing the white. 😉
Which shade is calling your name—Rosewater Pink, Aqua Spritz, or Ivory?
